Two Teaching Methods – Different Results
Nikki told me a story about an 8th grader in her class who was traumatized by one comment, two years ago, from the teacher my wife replaced; we’ll call her Ms. Smith. The young girl, we’ll call her Jenny, was putting on make-up during class when Ms. Smith told her, “Please put away your make-up. I’m supposed to be the prettiest one in the classroom…†Jenny was only in 6th grade and feeling pretty is very, very important. She couldn’t believe her teacher would say such a thing. Nikki, the student teacher at the time, noticed Jenny’s lips turn into a frown as she shoved her make-up back in her bag.
Nikki is now the teacher and runs her class from a different perspective. The class finished their work and they were telling stories about Ms. Smith. One girl said how mean Ms. Smith was and Jenny agreed and told everyone the “Make-up†story. Nikki was shocked at how Ms. Smith’s joke affected Jenny so deeply.
It’s been over two years and Jenny still holds a grudge against Ms. Smith. It’s amazing how impressionable a person can be when it hits so close to a fear. Jenny was at the stage of wanting to be pretty and have guys notice her and that one comment whacked Jenny right where it hurt most, her physical beauty.
My wife wrapped up the story and told me that she took a mental note when she saw Jenny so upset.
“I told myself that I would never approach the situation like that. If anyone takes out their make-up I tell them, ‘You are so beautiful that you don’t need make-up, so please put it away.’ They almost always smile, look away slightly embarrassed then agree and they actually enjoy putting their make-up back in their bag.â€
We all know the saying, “We attract more bees with honey than with vinegar.†But for some reason we have trouble putting away the vinegar bottle.













Larissa http://www.csphotographs.com
March 5th, 2007 at 7:34 pmWay to go Nikki for being perceptive enough to notice how these kinds of comments negatively affect people! Sometimes I just happen to stumble upon a memory such as “Jenny’s” that to this day makes me feel bad. I push it away quickly, but these thoughts surface nonetheless. As we work toward ways to deal with the way other people’s comments and actions make us feel in our daily life, I think it is equally important to think about how our words and actions are affecting the people around us. By treating people that way we would like to be treated, we can work on kindness and forgiveness at the same time - an important life lesson. Good entry, Karl!
Karl http://karlstaib.com
March 5th, 2007 at 8:20 pmThanks Larissa! You have such a nice way of explaining an additional perspective. It will certainly help others understand how treating each other with kindness can improve our lives.